Spain
has had some good media reports recently – if only from abroad. It started in
December with Italy’s L’Espresso naming
Sánchez the person of the year. The New Statesman followed
with an enthusiastic write-up, and an article late last month at the FT said
that ‘Spain leads the formerly weak southern EU economies that are now
outpacing France and Germany’. The
Spanish economy is doing
well, there are plenty
of tourists and the appreciation of Spain’s
culture domestically, says the Government, is on the increase.
But
let’s jump to where Spain’s brand of socialism is taking the country
today.
The
New York Times just last week ran an article written
by Sánchez himself: ‘I’m the Prime Minister of Spain. This is why the West needs
migrants.’ Yes, one-sided you might say, after all, he wrote it to justify his
policies; but look where it shows up!
His
‘guest essay’ appeared to diss President Trump: ‘…What should we do with these
people? Some leaders have chosen to hunt them down and deport them through
operations that are both unlawful and cruel. My government has chosen a
different way: a fast and simple path to regularize their immigration status…’.
Furthermore, he writes, the plan ‘…is endorsed by more than 900 nongovernmental
organizations, including the Catholic Church, and it has the support of
business associations and trade unions alike. More important, it is backed by
the people’. The Guardian picks
up on this with: ‘Yes, migrants are key to Spain’s economic boom. But Pedro
Sánchez’s decision to regularise 500,000 people should rather be applauded for
its humanity’.
Spain
is getting used to bucking Western political trends. ‘Last year they recognized
Palestine as a state, resisted President Trump’s demand that NATO members
increase their defence spending to 5% of GDP and doubled down on diversity,
equity, and inclusion programs. But there can be no better example of Spain
going its own way than with immigration’.
Or
perhaps we could argue the merits of the new proposal to ban the use of social
media for the under-sixteens. ‘First’, said Sánchez at the World Governments
Summit in Dubai last week, ‘We will change the law
in Spain to hold platform executives legally accountable for the many
infringements taking place on their sites’.
Do
Spaniards support restricting social media for children?
A
Spanish poll a year ago asked whether
children under 14 should be banned from using social media: 82% agreed. The
current plan of course is for the under-16s.
The
Spectator
(that bastion of British Conservative thought) says ‘Spain’s PM
is on the right side of this battle’.
The
X and Telegram owners don’t like the idea – with Elon Musk calling
Sánchez ‘a dirty tyrant and traitor to the people of Spain’ and Pavel Durov
writing in
a long screed on Telegram directly to his Spanish subscribers
(including the under-sixteens), that ‘the measures announced by Sánchez are not
safeguards, but rather steps toward total control to censor his critics, and that
they must fight for their rights’.
Could
other apps – maybe purely commercial ones – feel encouraged to
send out to subscribers their political opinions?
Sánchez
answered this on X with
an apparent allusion to Don Quixote: "Let the techno-oligarchs bark,
Sancho, it's a sign that we're riding forwards."
It’s
certainly a special moment: where a foreign businessman can circumnavigate The
State and appeal with propaganda aimed directly at his Spanish followers.
Internet
access is starting at increasingly
younger ages, and it's not just teenagers who are hyperconnected. 42% of
children admit to having browsed the internet before the age of eight, and half
of 15-year-olds spend at least thirty hours a week in front of a screen,
according to an OECD report.
There
will be problems: What age verification systems will be used? How will concerns
about the privacy risks of providing proof of age be addressed? To what extent
will adult access to social media be restricted to protect minors?
Beyond showing fluffy kittens
and creating social bonding, we read that the
threats from social media are many, and over half of all teens have
experienced some form of cyberbullying,
damage in self-esteem, sexual threats, misleading content, scams, risk-taking,
challenges, hate-speech and dodgy advertising and claims.
And, for that matter, with less
sleep and time for other activities.
In all, Pedro Sánchez
demonstrates that the obligation of a good government is to look out for and protect
its people, not someone else’s billionaires.